Mao Zedong Versus Santa Claus

Today is the day after Christmas and the spirit still hangs in the air (especially if you’re like me and your Christmas is a five-day multi-state slog between family homesteads.)  It is also the birthday of Mao Zedong (born 1893).  With that in mind, who really rules the season?* I say we sort this out once and for all, so with apologies to both Dr. Jack Ramsay and Bill Simmons,** let’s break this down, Dr. Jack style:

RED OR EXPERT?

Santa Claus definitely brings the red. It’s a key part of his fashion palette, plus you have poinsettias, holly berries, candy canes, Reindeer noses, etc. That said, is there any doubt? Mao may have frequently dressed in a suit of “Christmas tree” green but he was all about the Red: Red Army. Red Book. Red Guard.

ADVANTAGE: Mao

IDEOLOGY?

One of the two is famous for seizing goods produced by an enslaved, isolated population and redistributing them to people deemed to be worthy of receiving said goods based on an arbitrary set of lists that his minions check every year judging people on their ability to adhere to previously announced ideological guidelines.  The other is Mao.

ADVANTAGE: Draw

ORGANIZATIONAL ABILITY?

Mao compelled a billion people to abandon their fields and spend

Samuel Huntington and the Crassness of Culture

Samuel Huntington, a legend in academia, passed away on Christmas Eve at the age of 81.  Like them or loathe them, his ideas were highly influential among scholars, policy makers, and the reading public.  His 1996 book, The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order theorized that the world was divided into cultural ‘zones’ and that the differences between those cultures would define the post-Cold War age.

Personally, I wasn’t a huge fan but that might be because I think culture is overrated.

That’s not to say that “culture” (as a thing, if a thing difficult to define) doesn’t exist nor that this thing “culture” is unimportant.  Rather, the excessive focus on culture (or nation, or ethnicity, pick your poison) tends to obscure as much as it illuminates, and in fact can be quite destructive.

‘Culturally incompatible’ is too often lobbed about by those opposed to ‘foreign’ concepts (such as, say, human rights in China or women’s rights in Saudi Arabia) as if such an ill-defined phrase could ever be the final word on a particular subject.  (The rhetorical equivalent of Michael Corleone hissing at his wife “Don’t ever ask me about my business” in the Godfather).*  Problems

日历

December 2008
M T W T F S S
« Nov   Jan »
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031