ObaMao and Justin Timberlake: The state of the Sino-US relationship

It’s a sunny day in the hutong, cold outside but the sun is shining nicely off the snow packed on the roof of our kitchen and bathroom and reflecting brilliantly into the living room.  We moved our plants inside two weeks ago and they are enjoying the sun bath almost as much as the two cats, currently going at it UFC-style for largest patch of sunbeam on the couch.

Much happening in Beijing this week the arrival of two celebrated visitors.  President Obama touches down later this week (more on this in a moment), and Richard of The Peking Duck makes his triumphant return to the city of snow and smog after his much lamented mid-summer departure.

Lots has also been made of Qin Gang’s ill-advised historical analogizing.  Many Chinese netizens (the usual suspects) are applauding the Foreign Ministry spokesperson’s linkage of the CCP’s handling of the Tibet with the President Lincoln and the American Civil War.  Others, perhaps with a little more nuance and perspective, are questioning the wisdom of Qin Gang.  China watchers are used to daft historical statements made by cadres and officials for domestic Chinese consumption, but this was the Foreign Ministry trying to make a

Karl Eikenberry and the lessons of Vinegar Joe

President Obama is flying to Asia this week with much on his mind: Should the US commit another 40,000 troops to the war in Afghanistan as stories of official incompetence and political corruption leak daily from the capital of Kabul?

If Britain’s curse was her imperial ambitions, the United States has its hegemonic aspirations.  We are once again supporting a regime in a country turned hostile against both the United States.  Our support is critical to the success of the current Afghan government, but it is that very (and very public) support which may well ultimately doom the administration of Hamid Karzai as it did to Fulgencia Batista or the government of South Vietnam following the assassination of Ngo Dinh Diem.

Three simple rules:

In wars of attrition, the longer it lasts the greater the advantage for the home team. No matter how noble a politician may be, the more he depends on an outside force to maintain his position and power, the less legitimate his administration will seem in the eyes of his fellow countrymen. If you have your own people on the ground, listen to them.  They’re seeing things you’re not.

All of these rules apply to the

Morning tea: Snow, the blues, and the “Last Empress”

Things read and noted:

In the WSJ, Melanie Kirkpatrick reviews Hannah Pakula’s new biography of Song Meiling: The Last Empress.  Given that the only other major work to focus on Madame Chiang Kai-shek is Sterling Seagrave’s wretched Soong Sisters you gotta figure that there’s no where to go but up for Ms. Pakula.  On a side note, one of my students, fresh from seeing The Great Enterprise (建国大业), made a point of informing my history class that Song Meiling was by far the hottest part of the Chinese revolution.  Eleanor Roosevelt put it perhaps more pithily when she remarked that Madame Chiang was a women who spoke so eloquently about democracy despite not seeming to understand it at all. More snow in Beijing.  As a New Englander who feels that snow is an integral part of the winter (if not exactly November) experience, I’m loving this.  Beijingers, many of whom purchased earned their drivers licenses in the past  two years, not so much.  Not a good week to be flying in and around North China either.  Rumors abound about how much of this is the handiwork of Beijing’s weather gnomes… Finally, nothing to do with China but very cool nonetheless,

Bad History: Qin Gang joins the Tea Party Movement

I’ll admit it. I’ve been remiss about writing.  Just know that my time has been well spent teaching history and writing dissertations.  But when historians go on blogging vacation, it’s history that suffers.  Really.

In the US we have the wingnut brigade comparing President Obama’s health care reform plan to the Nazi Holocaust.

Not to be outdone, PRC historian-on-the-job Qin Gang decided that with President Obama not feeling the love at home, he’d welcome him to China by comparing the PLA’s ‘liberation’ of Τibet in 1951 to President Lincoln freeing the slaves.  I had to check twice to make sure this wasn’t some kind of Onion story that got accidentally mixed up in the wires.

Nope, he was serious.

I’m the first to admit that Τibet in the early 20th century was hardly a paradise on earth and, like many places in what is today the PRC, people suffered from the depredations of warlord armies, acquisitive foreign powers, and avaricious local elites BUT…

…to compare it to the systematic and brutal enslavement of the African people by European and American slave traders is just preposterous.  It is also sadly representative of the kind of tin-eared and muddle-minded approach to history

日历

November 2009
M T W T F S S
« Oct   Dec »
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30